Dennis L.A. White
Chris Walker
Charles Durning
Kris Kringle
Arthur Colombino
Jesus Christ
Tony Todd
God
Wilson Jermaine Heredia
Satan
Donna Bostany
Christie
Maribeth Mooney
Virgin Mary
Alison Whitney
Mary Magdalene
Ken Del Vecchio
Mario Vigilante
S.J. Hannah
Black Jesus
Anthony Cumberbatch Jr.
Elf
Sean Allison
Elf
Blanche Baker
Delores Kelly
Michael Boatman
Walter Wayne
Matt Ballard
Dennis
Allegra Cohen
Robin
Keith Collins
Troy
Heather Bunch
Hot Girl
Sara Christal
Hot Girl
Crystal Rolon
Hot Girl
Anthony Falco
Judge Milton
Frank Gigante
Court Officer
Penny Flick
Susie
Armen Garo
Pop
Randy Jones
R.J.
Molly Leland
Julia
Nicol Paone
Patti Kelly
Rachael Robbins
Jessie
Daniel Mesrobian
George the Cowboy
Erika Smith
Sonya
Crew