Seth Peterson
Robbie Levinson
Bruce Davison
Pastor Boyd
Chad Donella
Chris Boyd
Cindy Pickett
Barbara McCoy
Brian J. Smith
Trey McCoy
Susan Blakely
Martha Boyd
Lin Shaye
Kathleen Slansky
Farah White
Det. Elizabeth Fisher
Giancarlo Esposito
Detective Esposito
Sean Hennigan
Jim McCoy
Brandy Little
Stella
Ben Bathman
Connor Davis
Luke King
Alton Kachim
Earl Browning III
Detective Loy
Scarlett McAlister
Doctor Kucera
Connor Gewin
4-year-old Trey
Tyler Farris
10-year-old Trey
Trevor Sterling Stovall
Fisher's Son
Jason Hair-Wynn
Boy in Jail (uncredited)
Preston Strother
Boy in Church (uncredited)
Tyler Strother
Boy in Church (uncredited)
Cyrus Thompson
Boy in the Park (uncredited)
Tom Marcantel
Father Tim
Hana Kapp
Salesperson
Cas Dodgen
Policeman
Brock Cravy
Young Man
Kellie Rasberry
Carla, Robbie's Coworker
Dee Hennigan
Daycare Teacher
Keni LaTronico
Robbie's Mother (as Keni la Troncio)
Vernon Reeves
Seth's Father
Juan Gonzalez
Private Investigator
Heidie
Phoebe
Libby Villari
Shirley
Delia Rose
Church Member (as Delia Johnson)
Jenn Wright
Church Officer #1
Joe L. Blevins
Deacon (uncredited)
Nathan Childs
Police Officer (uncredited)
Phil Harrington
Doctor on Ward (uncredited)
Aaron Holt
CSI Agent (uncredited)
Christopher Holt
Sunday School Boy (uncredited)
Jennifer Holt
Child on Playground (uncredited)
Kevin Holt
Day Care Boy (uncredited)
Nicole Holt
Detective / Funeral Guest (uncredited)
Phillip Lanier
Choir Singer (uncredited)
Tiffany McManus
Sunday School Kid (uncredited)
Jimmy Paleschic
Crime Scene Investigator (uncredited)
Sloane Schoeneberg
Church Member (uncredited)
Summer Selby
Precinct Worker (uncredited)
