Season 1

Special guest Jenn Wasner of Bon Iver & Wye Oak joins us to decide whether Cricket or Robby has the best Batman script

Special guest Ed Schrader of Ed Schrader's Music Beat joins us to see who's Tossed Salad and who's Scrambled Eggs in this Frasier edition of the Fan Fiction Showdown

Special guest Luke Taylor of the Shrimp Boys eats Robby's senzu beans and makes him cry on this DBZ themed edition of Fan Fiction Showdown.

Special guest Lorelei Ramirez joins us for a very sexy and city-y episode.

Special Guest Jerry Paper joins us for the Star Trek episode of Fan Fiction Showdown, where we learn that the things that we like don't make us interesting.

Get out your raisins because special guest Geoff Graham is here for a scrummy episode all about the Great British Bake Off.

Actual television writer Gonzalo Cordova joins us for the Sesame Street edition - where we finally find out if Elmo has blood.

Special guest Kyle Mizono breaks her main bone when Robby and Cricket face off with their American Healthcare System fan fiction.

Special guest Ayo Edebiri is an actual successful person who joins our show to read Robby & Cricket's X-Man fan fiction!

Gold Dust Woman/special guest Sarah Squirm joins us for the season finale... will someone win in a "LANDSLIDE"? Get it?